S Corp Owners Must Balance Salary and Distributions Carefully
Accounting expert David Riggs outlines how S corp owners should set reasonable compensation to stay compliant and reduce payroll tax exposure.
S corporation owners who draw income from their businesses face a two-part compensation structure that carries significant tax implications, according to accounting expert David Riggs, writing in HelloNation. Before taking any shareholder distributions, working owners are required by IRS rules to pay themselves a reasonable salary subject to payroll taxes — a distinction that can attract scrutiny if handled incorrectly.
Riggs identifies several factors that determine what qualifies as reasonable compensation, including the owner's specific duties, professional experience, hours devoted to the business, and what a comparable employee in the same role would earn in the open market. The IRS uses those same benchmarks when auditing S corporations, making documentation essential rather than optional.
Read more Underinsured Motorist Coverage: What Gaps Could Cost You →
The practical risk for owners who set artificially low salaries is straightforward: shifting income away from wages and into distributions reduces payroll tax obligations, but the IRS treats that maneuver as a red flag. When auditors reclassify distributions as wages, the resulting back taxes, penalties, and interest can significantly outweigh any short-term savings the strategy produced.
Supporting records are central to Riggs's guidance. Maintaining written documentation that ties a salary figure to objective criteria — comparable market data, time logs, or a formal compensation analysis — gives owners a defensible position if the IRS ever challenges their methodology. Without that paper trail, even a genuinely reasonable salary can be difficult to justify under examination.
The broader takeaway from Riggs's analysis is that S corp compensation planning is not a set-and-forget decision. As a business grows and an owner's role evolves, the reasonable salary threshold should be reviewed periodically to reflect current responsibilities and market conditions. Continue reading at All Financial Services & Investing.
